Your Baby/Toddler’s Temperament Is More Relevant to Sleep Than You Think
(and why knowing it makes everything feel a lot less confusing)
If you’ve ever found yourself whispering, “Why won’t you sleep the way the books say you should?” welcome. You’re not doing anything wrong. Your baby’s temperament has more to do with their sleep than any schedule, wake window, or trick on Instagram.
Let’s break down the most common temperament styles and how they show up at bedtime.
The Three Big Temperament Styles
1. Easy / Flexible
These little peaches are generally calm, adaptable, and predictable with eating and sleeping. They don’t rock the boat, which means sometimes their needs get overlooked.
Sleep note: They may not loudly tell you they’re overwhelmed, so being intentional about connection still matters.
2. Spirited / Feisty / Active
Big energy. Big feelings. Big everything. These babies react intensely, struggle with noise or sudden changes, and resist transitions like it’s their job.
Sleep note: They thrive with preparation, redirection, and lots of chances to move their bodies.
3. Deep Thinker / Cautious / Slow-to-Warm-Up
Sensitive to new people and environments, they observe first and participate later.
Sleep note: Predictability, routine, and slow introductions to anything new help them feel safe.
A Special Note on Highly Sensitive Babies
Some babies feel the world with the sensitivity of a tuning fork. Sounds, textures, light, temperature shifts, even your mood, everything lands deeply.
These babies are more prone to fight, flight, or freeze responses, and their sleep gets disrupted easily. If you have one, you might constantly wonder, “What am I missing?”
You are not alone, and nothing is wrong. Sensitive babies often need:
more protection from overwhelm
more consistency
more co-regulation
sometimes support for underlying issues such as tension, ties, sensory overload or reflux
If that sounds like your little one, reach out. I can help you sort through what is temperament and what might be an underlying stressor.
Why Temperament Matters So Much for Sleep
Sleep struggles often come down to stress. Too much stimulation, too little movement, too many changes, too many unfamiliar faces, and a whole list of other things can overload a small nervous system. Babies cannot down-regulate stress alone.
Babies can “self-soothe” but they cannot self-regulate.
The term self soothing originally described babies who stopped signaling for help, not babies who were actually calm. Their brains are not wired for true down regulation yet. They use your nervous system as their regulator.
If you want to dive deeper, Dr. Greer’s Nurture Revolution, Gabor Maté, and Dr. Gordon Neufeld are phenomenal resources.
Temperament Deep Dives
Here’s how each temperament type shows up emotionally and what that means for sleep.
Spirited or Strong-Willed Babies
They feel big. They express big. Their emotions erupt like mini volcanoes, often over tiny things like “You peeled the banana wrong.”
Your job is not to stop the volcano.
Your job is to be the safe, steady mountain next to it.
What helps:
Normalize the feelings. These releases are healthy.
Stay calm. Your regulation becomes theirs.
Empathize instead of fixing. “You are so upset right now. I am right here.”
Avoid criticism or shame. It only teaches them to hide emotion.
What this builds:
Over time, as the brain matures, your child connects the limbic system with the frontal lobe. That is true self-regulation, and they learn it through your consistent support.
And don’t forget: a spirited child grows into an adult who is confident, determined, powerful, and a natural leader.
Easy-Going or Flexible Babies
Our sweet golden babies. They go with the flow, sometimes too much. These kiddos often hide their needs to keep the peace, which can lead to bottled-up emotions and hidden stress.
What helps:
Invite their voice. “Do you want this or that?”
Normalize the full range of feelings. Not just the happy ones.
Let them have their moments. Tears, protests, frustration, it is all healthy.
Avoid rescuing too fast. You don’t need to patch every upset. Your empathy is enough.
What this builds:
Self-worth. Assertiveness. Emotional safety.
An easy-going child who knows their voice matters becomes a confident and grounded adult, not a people pleaser.
Sleep and Temperament
A More Peaceful Home
Regardless of temperament, here is the heart of it:
Emotions drive behavior
Behavior impacts sleep
You are the regulator
Connection is the bridge that helps your child settle
Make space for feelings during the day, stay present at night, and match your support to your child’s temperament. When you understand how they are wired, everything such as bedtime, naps, and transitions becomes clearer and gentler.
Your baby is not giving you a hard time.
They are having a hard time, and you are the safe place they return to.
Wondering what else is important to know when it comes to preparing for infant sleep? Check this out:
Parenting is easier when the information actually makes sense. The Connected Sleep Foundations Bundle brings together my most supportive, evidence-informed resources to help you understand infant sleep through biology, connection, and realistic expectations. This is the guidance I wish I’d had when my daughter was born. Simple, grounding, and rooted in what babies actually need.
This bundle helps you cut through the noise, feel confident responding to your baby, and create safe sleep setups based on your real life, not someone else’s ideal schedule. It teaches you what’s normal, what’s not, and how to support your baby without ever using separation or sleep training.
You’ll learn how infant sleep truly works, how to safely share space at night, how to spot underlying issues, and how to support your own mental health while caring for your baby. Everything inside is designed to help you lean into connection, protect breastfeeding, and trust your instincts.
What You’ll Get Support With:
Understanding Normal Infant Sleep
Finally make sense of why your baby wakes, why closeness helps, and what is actually expected in the first year.
Safe Sleep That Works in Real Homes
Clear, practical guidance for room-sharing, bedsharing, chest sleeping, contact naps, and safe setups that meet current evidence without fear-based messaging.
Supporting Your Baby’s Body and Nervous System
Learn how body tension, oral ties, temperament, and stress can affect sleep, plus gentle tools that help your baby feel more comfortable and regulated.
Red Flags to Watch For
Honest, easy-to-understand signs that something might need a closer look, without sending you down a panic spiral.
Helping You Rest Better Too
Simple strategies for maximizing your rest, protecting your mental health, and creating a calmer rhythm in your home.
Gentle Transitions When You’re Ready
A respectful approach for moving from bedsharing to a bassinet without tears, pressure, or breaking trust.
Answers to Common “What About…” Questions
Wake windows, swaddles, white noise, sleep training, pacifiers, and all the things parents are told they “should” or “shouldn’t” do.
Why Parents Love This Bundle:
It’s attachment-focused and breastfeeding-supportive
It’s gentle and realistic
It helps you trust your instincts instead of fighting them
It respects your baby’s biology
It gives you options without guilt or pressure
Everything is written in a way exhausted parents can actually absorb
I created this bundle to help you feel prepared, not pressured. Supported, not scared. Connected, not confused.
Get the Connected Sleep Foundations Bundle for $27 and feel calmer, more confident, and more in sync with your baby.
Please download your files within 24 hours of purchase.
